I've stayed here many times over a 30 year time span and always enjoyed it.
Several years ago the owner and his wife were killed in a tragic auto accident, things were in a turmoil and the property suffered.
The bad reviews are all dated during this time.
Check out the newer reviews and you will see things have changed.
I am personally booking 2 cabins this summer.
Like I said, give it a chance. It's a beautiful spot.
This is not the Hilton. The cabins are rustic, but clean and nice.
A great lake experience.