We were excited to eat at Hemingways again after a long time away. We remembered a great atmosphere, good food and friendly people. I guess two out of the three isn't too bad except we would have much preferred the food to still be a wonderful memory. We were intending to order off the menu but the waitress suggested the buffet as it had some of the items on it that we were going to order. Not a good choice. Such a disappointment. The food was very bland, served lukewarm and overcooked. The shrimp was chewy as were the clam strips and catfish portions. Actually, the entire buffet was below average. On a more positive note, the atmosphere and friendly staff is still there but sadly, we will not be going back to what was once a wonderful restaurant.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.