As a Columbia resident for all of my life, I can easily say that Coley's is my favorite restaurant in town. My boyfriend and I come here frequently (they have $4 Martini's!). The food is ALWAYS excellent, and although the menu is small, the selection is varied (both in cuisine AND in price, which is appreciated). I always, always order the salmon, whether it's on the Grilled Salmon Salad (only $9.50), or the Glazed Salmon (the most expensive menu item, still < $20).
You absolutely MUST try the Pepperjack Mac & Cheese, and the Honey Bacon dressing. I have never tasted salad dressing like this!
The atmosphere is nice AND quiet, although my only complaint is with the chairs! They have really low arm rests, but other than that it seems like a nice, clean restaurant in a historic Columbia building!
As far as the Martinis go, I've tried them all! All are great, but my favorite is the X-rated and the key lime. They also have great sangria!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.