Good friends invited us to one of their very favorite mainstay restaurants and we were pretty excited, knowing what excellent cooks they themselves are. We were not disappointed. We both went for the Monday night special of filet medallions and were delighted ($12.95). One friend ordered spaghetti with meatballs which came loaded with shredded parmesan. The other got a large burger accompanied by excellent sweet potato fries. Our green beans were different and delicious, and the gargantuan baked potato was a meal in itself. Service was friendly, prompt and attentive. Its a pretty sure sign a place is good when you can see the server's pride and joy in their demeanor. The menu options were more than adequate and the prices were more than reasonable. Sal's is located in teensy Withrow, a burg north of Stillwater proper. We enjoyed the rural area and Sal's rustic charm, including the split log décor, stone fireplace and the casual atmosphere. Business was brisk and the overall experience was pleasing. I am looking forward to a return visit to this out of the way spot soon.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.