This is "the place that made New Buffalo famous." I like the joint overall, but I do believe it is a little over rated. The prices aren't bad, but they're also not great. 2 burgers, fries, and 2 drinks + tip came out to about $32. The burgers are good and the systematic organization of the hostesses and seatings is very impressive. Overall, if you have a taste for a burger and the wait is under 25 mins, I'd stop here every time.