I've eaten at the Gate House two summers in a row when visiting the island and it's my favorite. The atmosphere is casual, I love the outdoor seating and the food is delicious! I definitely recommend starting with a cup of the Golden Ale Turkey Chili Verde. It's delicious and you can customize it to your liking as it's served with a side of sour cream to cool it down or green chili sauce to spice it up! This year I tried the Avocado Chicken Egg Rolls as my meal (it's listed as an appetizer) and they were absolutely phenomenal. My dining companion got the Trapper Burger with steak fries and he loved it as well. I definitely recommend it!