We had heard good things about this place, but it was honestly one of the worst restaurant experiences we've ever had. Thank goodness we had a gift certificate or I don't think we would have stayed past the appetizer -- especially not at those prices! First, we arrived at 7pm and were one of 2 tables seated in the whole restaurant. Awkward? Then we ordered the appetizer special which was lobster bisque-- except it was brown and smelled like mushrooms and tasted like rotten cream-- no lie. And there were no lobster chunks in it.. I'm not sure this was the chef's creative take on lobster bisque. We've never sent food back in a restaurant before but this was just wrong. The other food (duck, filet mignon) was... ok... but not worth the $40 price tag per entree, especially not when there are other amazing places on the island like l'etoile, Sweet Life, or Lambert's Cove, at the same price. I think the owner really does take pride in the place so it's really too bad.. they are just out of touch at this point. The only reason we give it 2 stars is because our server was great.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.