I dined at Betsy's with a group of 7 friends recently. Like some of the other reviewers, we did have to wait to be seated despite having a reservation but to be fair we had arrived ten minutes early (completely out of character for 8 girls!) and we made some great friends in the bar during that time.
It was worth the wait, the food was fantastic. The majority of our party had the tuna special and all agreed it was awesome. Other highlights included the ravioli in red pepper sauce (yum). Honorary mentions go to the bruschetta starter and also the calamari. One member of our party had the shrimp pasta and was slightly worried when she had to decide how many shrimp to order (they are priced individually) but when it arrived she was pleasantly surprised and decided that 4 shrimp really was optimal!! Definitely try the Little Black Dress red wine also.
Besides the food, it was the atmosphere in the restaurant that really made our evening. Betsy stopped by a couple of times and was so friendly and interested in what we thought of the food. Our waiter had an entertaining sense of humor - when asked for water when he was ready he replied "You can't wait until I'm ready honey, I'll get it for you now". Also our new friends from the bar were seated at the next table and kept us entertained including singing Happy Birthday to Betsy. It was great - the whole restaurant joined in the singsong.
Overall, we have a very enjoyable meal and would definitely dine there next time we go to P'town.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.