A visit to Edgartown would not be complete without a stop at Mad Martha's. Simply stated, the ice cream is wonderful. Great variety and marvelous creamy taste. I would give it an excellent rating except for the fact that the service is slow and consequently the line is often very long. The staff is pleasant and tries hard, but the set up is inefficient. All takeout pints and quarts are hand packed when they are ordered. This is time consuming and labor intensive. I have often wondered why they don't get some pints and quarts of vanilla and chocolate ice cream packed in the morning when they are not busy so that they would be available during busy times.
Also, be forewarned, the ice cream is expensive.