My husband and I treated ourselves to an overnight stay in Edgartown in mid-January. I already knew about the Kelley House and I had eaten at the restaurant several times, so I called up to make a reservation. Nickie was very helpful in spite of admitting she hadn't taken a reservation for a while because she didn't usually work the front desk. She did fine! The lobby was so welcoming with its fire in the fireplace when we checked in that later on we settled ourselves in front of the fire in the comfy chairs. Tea available for the asking, so we asked and we received. Too bad those evening cookies aren't available in the afternoon. Our room was really nice and the bed was comfortable. When I reported to the staff the taps were dripping, they promptly moved us rather than make everyone wait around for the engineering staff to show up. Our new room was also large with a very comfortable king bed, and as a corner room in the main house had more windows and better view. I appreciate that kind of solution to a room problem. It was very quiet in Edgartown with the holiday season over, especially on a Monday, so we had a nice walk around a very quiet town, no shopping to be had. The hotel staff were all friendly and helpful and ready to offer suggestions of places to visit and to eat, even though they do play up their own pub, Newes from America. And we did eat there because it was one of two open restaurants walking distance from the hotel! We enjoyed the meal and would recommend the burgers and beer to anyone. The next morning we had a coffee and muffin that the hotel puts out, nice touch, but we did walk up to Espresso Love Café for latte and breakfast sandwich. Normally I would recommend the Dock Square Coffee Shop, but it was closed for a few days so we weren't able to have breakfast there as we would otherwise have done. Kelley House has a great central location, and a great staff that really wants you to enjoy everything about your stay at the hotel, in Edgartown, and on the Vineyard.
- Reservation Options:
- TripAdvisor is proud to partner with Booking.com, Travelocity and Hotels.com so you can book your Kelley House reservations with confidence. We help millions of travelers each month to find the perfect hotel for both vacation and business trips, always with the best discounts and special offers.
- Also Known As:
- Kelley House Hotel Edgartown
- Kelley House Edgartown, MA - Martha's Vineyard