I have been going to Captain Frosty’s for years – always loved it. I was concerned after reading a few average reviews, but returned and had my usual great meal.
They have some of the very best fried seafood on the cape, all at a very good value. For those who have not been there – it is not a fancy place, and it can be crowded. You wait in line (always) to place your order, they give you a number and the wait staff brings you your food and drinks. They come out hot and ready to eat, so occasionally your table will not get all the food at once, much better that than keeping some of the dishes under the heat lamps. I am partial to the Fisherman’s Platter (cod, scallops, whole belly clams, shrimp, fries, clam fritters and coleslaw) it is great, but it is a lot of food – the fish and chips plate uses cod, is reasonably priced and is a normal amount of food.
They also have an ice cream stand – but I am always too full to try it!