I had two problems with this restaurant. The first was the cheap furniture, hokey neon signs at the bar and general low-rent crab shack feel to the place that was totally at odds with the $30-$40 entree prices on the menu.
My main problem was the desperately inexperienced waitstaff that rushed my wife and I through our meal. The main course arrived within a minute of us finishing our starters. While eating our main course we were interrupted to be asked if we wanted coffee, and we said yes assuming it would come with our desserts. Seconds later two cups of coffee appeared on the table - while we were still eating and our wine bottle was still half full! We had three courses yet were out the door within 45 minutes of sitting down, and about $200 lighter. We had some good meals in Chatham but this wasn't one of them. The food was unmemorable and overpriced for what it was. Never again.