I'd rate this place more a 3.5, than just 3. We ate at the bar since the restaurant was hopping at lunchtime. Atmosphere is very nice. Bartender never asked if we wanted water with our meal (we ordered wine). My husband and I both ordered the oyster sandwich with house made potato chips. Chips were good. The oysters were a little over cooked. We wish they offered a choice of rolls. The oyster roll is a bulky baguette so there's a lot to eat. We ate the oysters and left the rolls. If you want hungry man sized sandwiches, then this is your place. If you're retired and don't eat as much as you used to, you might want to share a sandwich or take some home.