One star minus only because of a few details that could have been done better. We were early arrivals, celebrating a wedding anniversary. The quiet was nice, because the dining room got noisy before we left. My wife had lobster, but had to ask for a bowl for the shells, and a small fork for the task. A bib wouldn't have been to inelegant to offer. I had the scallops Nantucket. I am still not convince that mozarella and bacon really compliment scallops. Butter was served as foil wrapped patties - a pain to unwrap with resultant greasy fingers. I would expect this at Dennys, but not an expensive restaurant. The sour cream was just a jab. The vegetables were fresh and nicely sauteed. My wife loved the chocolate cake. The coconut sorbetto was wonderful, but, although the coconut shell as serving dish was cute, it was impossible to eat without holding the shell with one hand, resulting in a chocolate sauce mess.
All in all, a nice dining experience with excellent service. The rest of the menu looked intriguing, but very much on the pricey side.