I have always wanted to try this bakery, but it's never been open when I've been here in years past. Well, finally, this was my lucky year! This is a small bakery with a cute gift shop attached to it. I had a hard time choosing from all the flavors of muffins and cookies offered. The peach muffin and the lemon crumb muffin were both good, but the cookies were on another level altogether! The peanut butter cookie had a crackly, sugary outside and a chewy, moist inside. The Hershey Kiss on top was still melty - you know what I mean if you've ever made peanut butter kiss cookies before! My husband was very lucky that I offered to share half of the cranberry lemon cookie with him. It was so good, that i did NOT offer to share the final cookie of the 3 I bought, the cranberry white chocolate oatmeal cookie. Why oh why did I not buy more cookies? Well it's too late now, as I'm back home in Virginia. Please be open when i return to the Cape next time!