I am confused by my favorite website's reviews of Brewster restaurants. We bought into raving reviews of Peddler's, and it was the worst meal in a long time. Then we decided to take a risk and to go to Ardeo Mediterranean on Main Street, which was low on the tripadvisor ratings list (?!) because it was conveniently located.
What a great idea!
The room is pleasant, the hostess in remarkably efficient, the waiters are nice and professional.
We ordered five different dishes: steak, chicken, spinach salad, portobello, and fish. Everything was delicious, with a lot of taste to it. Filling, but not too heavy. Nicely and interestingly spiced and flavored, but not so spicy that it would be too hot.
The food was served promptly, and my son said that his tiramisu was impeccable.
Ardeo Mediterranean would be my #1 recommendation to a dear friend in Brewster. I would come here as soon as I have a chance. So many other dishes to try on the long and varied menu...
My rating would be: Ardeo- #1 in Brewster; Paddler's - #don't do it! In Brewster.
In case you wonder - I am a random first time tourist here, traveling with family. We were all over Europe and the US, and we love discovering new restaurants.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.