Two stars because the food was tasty, not knock out great, and way too expensive for the quality.... but tasty and well presented. Service was REALLY not great. We had two birthday girls in our party 81 years and 18 years. I made a point to mention the special occasion when I made the reservation. There was NOT even a verbal happy birthday acknowledgment by any staff. Milton Inn uses faux bottled water... Let me explain... They fill your water glasses from green glass bottles that look as if they could be actual "bottled water" when in fact it's just cold tap water refilled into these green bottles. The problem is that the green bottle gulg gulg gulg as its being poured creating spillage on the table every time! Resting my arm on the table got my nicely ironed sleeve all wet from repeated gulg gulg spillage. At first i thought the young bus boys (hs students?) had not been trained well in how to pour water but as the evening wore on it became evident that no matter who poured the water glug gluged out creating more and more spillage. I even commented to one bus boy "oh my goodness that's messy". No response and no effort to correct the water spillage issue. Also this particular server had picked the bottle up out of a wine chilling bucket without wiping the bottom so that water and ice chips streamed down the sides and bottom of the bottle and added to the glug glug mess. (MIlton Inn choose another vehicle for table water delivery... your not fooling anyone we know its not bottled water and it makes a big mess). The food was ok as I mentioned and the presentation was attractive. We did not care for the grits side plate and the Caesar salad was way too fishy. However the ny strip, tenderloin, lobster, and salmon were all fine and tasty, cooked as ordered. We sat too long without attention and had to ask that the dinner plates be bussed. At an upscale restaurant you are paying for the experience, service and ambiance as well as the food. Sorry Milton Inn I'd like to support you because you are local but Milton Inn is NOT worth it for the money spent. Go to Prime Rib, Ruth Chris, etc for similar priced entrees and much much better service!