Okay, it was partially my fault for ordering chicken, which I haven't ordered in any restaurant for over 5 years. But I just found the menu so uninspiring, especially after seeing plain 'ol crabcake, scallops, fish, etc., on every menu in town. And I was intrigued by the bacon crepe the chicken came with. I did get raw oysters for an appetizers, which were good, and my wife's plain 'ol scallops were good, but the chicken was really dry, and the crepe was thick and chewy. Look very carefully at the menu before deciding to eat here. I thought the options at Purser's Pub were a little more unique (Oyster Pot Pie, anybody?) and more affordable.
Even if I had looked at the menu beforehand, I probably would have chosen Sherwood's Landing for a great service experience, but I won't make that mistake again! Water glass did not get filled a single time while we were there (until we asked when we asked for our check), and our empty plates (and empty water glasses) sat in front of us for a good 15 minutes before anybody checked to see if we were done or if they could remove our plates.
We should have gone back to St. Michaels Crab and Steakhouse or Marcoritaville for great seafood.
I still gave it a 3 because my wife did like her scallops and my oysters were decent. Otherwise it's a boring restaurant with poor service.