We went to Fager's Island for my birthday, I must say it was such a disappointment. This bar has a ridiculous policy of removing all bar stools whether you are sitting in them or not. We were asked to get out of our seats because they were removing all of the bar stools, I thought that was very rude! We have been to many places in many states and some places do remove stools/chairs if they are not being used, we have never been asked to get out our seats because they were taking them.
We ended up leaving after our seats were taken, it ruined our evening. If you don't like a heavily crowded bar scene, this is not the place for you.
We will not plan to visit Fager's Island again.