It's cafeteria seating, crowded & noisy, and the menu prices seem high. Step back and take a good look at your choices before ordering. Don't order that $25 lobster sandwich - you'll just be annoyed at yourself for trying to savor lobster amidst such craziness. The clam chowder is perfect & the Pilgrim sandwich is large enough to share. The panini sandwiches are excellent and the generous desserts are just plain fun. Get a couple of things, enjoy, get something else if you're still hungry. It's fast, informal and, best of all, you can go back to the store shelves after you've eaten and buy the ingredients to make the stuff at home. Wish I could run back to Maine tomorrow for another lunch at Stonewall's!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.