My family and I stopped here on our way through York. My brother, who lives in NH, had heard good things about Wild Willy's and had been wanted to try it. He said he people drive for miles around to get one of their burgers. I love a good burger, so that definitely got my attention. They have a lot of interesting burger combinations to choose from. I went simple. I got the bandito burger with grilled onions and cheddar cheese. I really wanted to taste the “Pineland Farms™ All Natural Beef”. Everyone in my party ordered their burger medium or medium rare and everyone got a well done burger. It was disappointing. Beef of this quality needs to be cooked carefully, because it tends to dry out when it’s overcooked. Don’t get me wrong it was still a decent burger just overcooked. I like a warm pink center. If I had known beforehand that they tend to overcook their burgers I would have gotten a burger smothered in BBQ sauce or some other spicy sauce they offer. Another low point was the fries. They make real hand cut french fries, but they came out limp and greasy. We also got an order of Poutine. The gravy was reminiscent of Thanksgiving dinner, but did help the fries a little. Overall this is not a bad place, but if I’m back in the York area this will not be someplace I come back too. If I lived locally, I would definitely give this place another try.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.