Sarah's is just wonderful. We stopped here for lunch on the way to Boothbay Harbor for the weekend, and fell in love with the food and atmosphere here after deciding not to wait in the ridiculously long line for Red's across the street. The "soup bar' is divine - three delicious soups to choose from, along with an abundance of homemade breads and focaccias! I ordered the #33, the lobster sandwich with the soup bar. The lobster sandwich was different than a typical lobster roll (lobster "salad" rather than whole chunks of meat), but was delicious. The honey oat homemade roll it was served on was the best part of the meal! Try the haddock chowder on the soup lineup - it was yummy.
On the way to our table, we passed the pie case, and I was mesmerized - the pies were beautiful. We were full after lunch and couldn't find room for pie but we loved Sarah's so much we drove back from Boothbay that night for dessert! The Apple Cranberry pie with crumb topping was the best I ever had (and I've had a lot of pie!), and my wife's Apple Blueberry was equally top shelf. We highly recommend Sarah's for lunch or dinner, and especially for all the baked goods. Can't wait to come back!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.