Portland Pie Company has eclipsed the long-time local king of the pizza hill, Ricetta's. Been going to this restaurant (and ordering take-out and delivery) for three years now (Both Portland and Scarborough locations.)
With its different crust options, size options, and myriad fresh toppings, this is a pizza lover's paradise. (I prefer the thin crust, which unfortunately is available only on 14" pizzas, keeps me from ordering an individual pizza, when really, that's all I want.)
A small complaint given the joy of a PPC pizza!
The Portland location could do with better parking. The Scarborough location has ample parking and seating since it's located in the Cabela's Mall area.
I confess never to ordering anything other than pizza, so I cannot comment on other menu items.