I'd first like to say that the only reason I tried this restaurant was due to the reviews it received from tripadvisor. I told my waitress that was why I came.
I got the clam bake, which was $50 for two, which I thought was a good price. We each got a 1lb lobster, roasted potatoes, mussels, steamers, and some vegetables. The vegetables were hard and tasteless, so we didn't eat them. There was kielbasa in the clam bake (they just bring one big pot to the table), which was tasty. The roasted potatoes were delicious when they first brought them out, but they got cold really quickly. My daughter got a casserole, which wasn't very good. That was either $23 or $24. That meal was very disappointing. My son got the baked haddock. It was not a large portion, but it was fresh and tasty ($20). The blueberry crumb cake was very good (with ice cream). The chocolate cake was much to rich (and for my son not to eat a $7.50 piece of cake was wasteful). The service was very good. So really, I would have liked to give this restaurant 3.5 starts -- but I rounded it up to four. Note: it will definitely cost you over $100 (probably closer to $125 without the tip) if you go with a family of four.