Was looking for a cozy spot to share a two year anniversary toast and appetizer while visiting Freeport. Conundrum was recommended and, although a bit out of the way from the center of town, it was just right. We received friendly, attentive table service in the bar. I was offered tastings from the wine menu before deciding on a delicious red blend. My sweetie is a margarita fan and we both were impressed by his. We shared a crab cake appetizer; not the best, but quite good.
If it wasn't for being expected by friends elsewhere, we would have easily succumbed to one of the inviting indoor or outdoor (enclosed patio) fireside seats. If we get back to Freeport, would certainly return to try dinner.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.