Friday night March 21 - arrived at 5:30 & already a waiting line: this is a popular place! Our party of 5 was seated in about 20 minutes. Server Lorenda was prompt in tending to us, but obviously VERY busy with a full dining room. Food was excellent and reasonably priced. We ordered a Fishermans' Platter, Mediteranean Salmon, a 2# lobster with steamers, Fried Oysters, and baked Haddock & Scallops Seafood Combo. Everyone was satisfied & happy. Interesting that no lemon slices were served with any dish ( may have come with the lobster).
Bay Haven is not fancy, but we weren't looking for or expecting fancy. Food portions are enormous - way too much to eat at one sitting! Curious that we made a reservation (we thought) earlier in the week, but when we called to confirm were told they don't take reservations!!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.