Waited all year to return to bay Haven for dinner. We have eaten here in the past and have even ordered large numbers of their lobster for take out so we were looking forward to returning to Bay Haven. Unfortunately, we were disappointed. The wait staff was very attentive and the atmosphere was great however, the meal was not up to their normal standards. My husband ordered the baked lobster tails and when his meal arrived, we thought he had been given the wrong meal. His lobster tails were so tiny that they actually looked like shrimp. The server took the meal back to the kitchen to make sure that it was the correct meal and when she brought it back, she apologized and said that in her opinion, they were extremely small and that she was embarrassed. Half way through our dinner, she brought my husband an extra lobster tail ( a small one but still a lobster tail ) . I ordered the triplet - a lobster dinner with 3 lobsters. They too were very, very small - just about 3 bites per lobster tail. The restaurant was not all that busy so it's not as if they ran out of food. I was taken aback by the difference in the portions compared to meals that we have had there in previous years. Would probably consider giving them a second chance based up past years performance but suffice it to say that we were very disappointed with our meals this go around. Otherwise, the prices are reasonable and the atmosphere, despite being very laid back and relaxed makes for a pleasant meal.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.