We went to this restaurant last night with some friends we haven't seen in a year. We suggested this restaurant because we had such a delicious meal last year (we visit Boothbay Harbor twice a year). First of all we were there after a bus group (but they were almost done eating) so we kind of knew that we had a little wait. The waiter (Jay) kept on messing up. We told him who would be on the checks (one party of 2 and one party of 3 and we pointed out who they were) Even after he repeated which was which he still got the checks wrong. The wait between our appetizer and our dinner was long and the food was warm to cool. My potato was so overcooked I only got 3 bites out of it and it looked like it had a tan inside. My Husband and I had stuffed haddock which was overcooked and very dry and the meal was not hot. The friends that we invited had decent meals but the waiter got the man's meal wrong (messed up the steaks with another friends surf/turf, he was to have prime rib) and the waiter never came back to check on us for a while. When we got the checks, he still got them wrong and had to get his attention to have him correct it. Our friends had to wait again because he didn't put the slip to sign for his credit card. We don't go out to eat much, but when we do, we expect to have a decent meal and service. This was the worst meal I have ever,ever had and as of today, would not go back. Very disappointing.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.