Tried to find this place last night. It was the anniversary of my beloved chow Nero's birthday. He passed in 2007 but when he was alive we always went for ice cream on his birthday, so I still do every year in his memory. We went crazy wandering around town trying to find this place after reading the great reviews, but after half an hour or so we gave up & went to the other shop in town. Today we went for lunch & decided to try finding it in the daylight thinking maybe they were only open weekends now that summer season has passed. We found the building-but Island Cow is no more! There is a massage therapy spa where it had been. So if you're in Boothbay looking for ice cream go straight to Downeast or you'll be searching til the cows come home!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.