I've eaten at Goodfellas more than 20x over the years , mainly because it was the only downtown afterhours choice for a while. The owners and staff rock, no denying that, very cool guys, but the gigantic, floppy slices of pizza will leave grease literally dripping from your elbows. Hard to believe people wait 45 minutes at bar closing time on weekends but they do. Great concept, great local business, but highly hyped and overrated pizza. Try it sober once.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.