My husband and I celebrated our 1st anniversary here on recommendations from friends. I love the quaintness of this restaurant. They gave us champagne for our anniversary when we first sat down and then took us to the kitchen to explore the butcher block - a display of scallops, prawns and even kangaroo for us to choose from. We signed the wall on the way back to the kitchen - loved seeing some of the kitchen. I had the strip steak which was delicious and my husband had the scallops - also very good. I would definitely recommend if you are celebrating a special occasion in St. Thomas.
Great wine selection as well!