My girlfriend and I, who live on island, were heading to Mahogany Grille on a Monday night when we realized it was closed so we decided to finally give Old Stone a chance. We were NOT disappointed! From the valet to the server assistant everyone was so wonderful and attentive. Their wine list is extensive yet affordable if you don't want to break the bank and their menu is finely crafted and updated daily. Definitely take a tour of the kitchen and see what the chef has on the butcher's block for that evening, such wonderful meats and seafood! Make sure to sign your name on the wall to while your in the kitchen too. We started off with bone marrow and a charcuterie, which was expertly explained by our server Tim, who was wonderful. I had the 8 oz ostrich filet off the chef's menu and my girlfriend had the coq au vin, both were AMAZING!! Definitely try a side of their stuffed tater tots too, they are delicious! Also we had beignets with cinnamon chocolate and an espresso chocolate dipping sauce for dessert and as a person that doesn't like dessert or espresso let me just say they were absolutely mind blowing. I highly recommend dinner here, especially for a great date night!! Ask for Tim as well, you won't be disappointed!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.