My fiancee and I recently visited St. Thomas; To celebrate of our engagement, we received a recommendation to dine at the Old Stone Farmhouse. Our evening could not have been more pleasant.
Lorraine looked after us all night long and did a great job of reseating us and recommending various items on the menu. An unexpected treat was the visit to the kitchen area where we spoke with the chefs and could preview the various proteins that were being prepared on that particular evening.
The preparations were spot on as far as temperature of the meats, and the notes of the individual components of the food played nicely off of each other. I've eaten at some fantastic restaurants in my travels, but the food at Old Stone is at the top of the list.
In short, we highly recommend this as a "must experience" while visiting St. Thomas.