My husband and I Just returned home from a week in St. Thomas with my sister and her husband. We had read about Old Stone Farmhouse and while they were golfing they actually got to see it since the cart path goes right by. So when we picked them up after golf, we stopped in to see about making reservations. The manager was fun, extremely pleasant, chatted with us for awhile, showed us a sample menu from the previous night - (the menu changes based on local and fresh ingredients - nice!!) We made our reservation and he even allowed us to walk through and request a table if available. We chose the "Wine Room" because we loved the stone walls, wall of wine and the full length doors/windows that would be opened in the evening. When we arrived, he remembered us, and we were seated in the location we desired. It was really nice. Our server was extremely friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. As others mentioned, she escorted us to the kitchen to see the special menu items and we did write our names on the wall and took photos. This was a fun way to mark a special evening with family. The sommelier was wonderful, he was also very knowledgeable and recommended the perfect wine pairings to accompany our meal. The appetizers were wonderful (asparagus soup, heirloom tomato salad, duck and oysters) as were our entrees (lamb, scallops and filet). My steak was outstanding and one of the best I've eaten (I'm from Kansas). The valet parking was a nice touch as was the hand created menu we got to keep. The only negative was the length of time from appetizer to entree, but we did tell them we were in no hurry and it gave us more time to enjoy each other's company and the beautiful surroundings.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.