We had heard great things about this place when we first moved to Bowling Green so we were really excited to try it. We went on Saturday afternoon and were the only customers there. I am hoping we just had a fluke experience and hopefully we may return and have a better one. Anyway, Lost River boasts about award winning pizza so we thought it had to be at least decent. Yikes. We were horribly disappointed. We ordered a "Chicago Style" supreme pizza. When the waitress brought it out, it looked great though I would have used a different pan to serve it on since the one it was on looked kind of gross and was warped so it would not sit flat on the table. When I tried to serve my husband a slice, all the toppings sloushed off and lo and behold, we realized the pizza was thin crust with a tall raised crust on the borders (to give the appearance of a true Chicago style pizza). The toppings from the rest of the pizza sloushed in where the we had taken slices out. There was NO sauce. A few (very few) tomatoes were sprinkled on top (I'm guessing this was the sauce?) The crust was super crispy and because the topping would not stay on, almost impossible to eat. For the amount we paid for our pizza, we expected a little better. Heck, even Little Caesar's has acutal thick crust! Like I said, I really hope it was simply a fluke and we went on a bad day but seriously guys, don't advertise a Chicago Style pizza if you aren't going to make it somewhat right. We will be returning only to give this place another chance. If you do decide to go, get the thin crust. I'm guessing that's what everyone who likes this place gets.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.