The pros: This is a neat little place with some great ambiance. The history of the bar is particularly interesting. I also thought the service was very good. The bourbon list was decent though not exceptional. That said, the pricing was fair and allowed for greater opportunities to try new things.
The cons: The food- bleh. At best, it was mediocre; at worst, it was bad. It is also very inconsistent between tables (we had a fried sampler and wound up with a plate full of batter bits; the people next to us ordered the same thing and had actual fried vegetables included in theirs). Other reviews seem to echo this theme - food is just not a strength at this place.
Conclusion: Go for a drink or two, but head elsewhere for edibles.