Being a Jersey boy and a transplant to Indiana 15 years ago, I had never been to Wanamaker or Wheatley's before but on Saturday morning we stopped at Wheatley's before the Russ Dellen Memorial Loop motorcycle ride.
We both got 1/2 orders of the biscuits & gravy and that was plenty as they put quite a bit into a carry out container. Yes, whether you are eating in or taking out, it comes in a takeout container.
No frills, no waitress, go up to the counter, order and carry it back and eat it.
Just GREAT biscuits and gravy.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.