I've been to the Indy Scotty's and it just doesn't hold up to the one in Muncie. I graduated from Ball State and we spent many evenings at Scotty's chowing down on dill pickle chips, burgers and drinking some of their beers. I haven't been disappointed with any of the food. It's always excellent. Service is good. Can sometimes get overcrowded, but typical in a college town. I always make sure I visit when we are in Muncie!