If I had written this after the first three visits here I would have given the highest marks. We have eaten here probably a dozen times and eight were great, two decent and two lacking. I was a little disappointed last time on our anniversary when we had reservation, but were seated in the bar - kind of noisy with TVs around is not the atmosphere I was looking for. The one time we had a really poor experience - we did ask to speak to a manager who gave us a gift certificate to come again. We did return because we had several good experiences. The cocktails are excellent and the wine list is great. The goat cheese salad and caprese salad are very good. The seafood pastas (change with the season) are always a solid choice. The beef is always excellent. Desserts are excellent. The service is uneven - usually quite good. If they could consistently perform this would go from very good to excellent - if they are "on" that night it is among the top three in town.