I went here by myself while in Indianapolis on business. The staff was extremely accomodating from the minute I walked through the door. I ate at a small table in the bar, with the bartender as a server and he was phenomenal. When I arrived, it was early so he was not busy, but by the time I left, he was hopping, but he never neglected me in the slightest. I had the shrimp cocktail since that's what they are famous for and it did not disappoint. If you have a head cold, go to St. Elmos and have the shrimp cocktail. The sauce will clear those sinuses right up. But it was AMAZING! Rather than have a full meal, I had the tenderloin chops appetizer and it was wonderful. Perfectly seasoned and cooked.....it was spectacular. Couple this spectacular dining experience with a couple of glasses of fine wine, and you have a winning evening. If you go to Indianapolis.....don't walk, RUN to St. Elmo's and you won't be disappointed. Worth every penny.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.