My husband and I dined here 2 nights ago for our anniversary. I was expecting so much based on the reviews that I read prior to dining here. While the atmosphere and service were excellent, I am sad that the food did not live up to any of the expectations. The crab cake appetizer was just okay, but I do not fault them for this as we are in the Midwest...the best crab cakes in this city are at Oceanaire. The sauce that they serve along with the cakes contributed to their success-- it was good. Unfortunately, the meal went downhill from there. The house salad was a sad presentation of mixed dark green lettuce, a few chopped tomatoes, and unimpressive parmesan--I have better cheese at home. Entrees were even more disappointing--the scallops were unevenly cooked, asparagus burnt, and the potatoes with duck confit were just downright greasy. My husband's bone-in pork chop with amaretto reduction was okay-probably the best thing we ordered. Even dessert couldn't save this meal--I am a big fan of cheesecake and have eaten it all over the world--their mascarpone cheesecake was stiff and flavorless. Again, I was disappointed and hope I save someone a trip. Mama Corrolla's in Broad Ripple is a much better choice for authentic non-chain Italian.