I wasn't quite sure what to think before I went. Don't often see such a wide range of reviews. I'm guessing this place is either really on or really off. Unfortunately for our party it was really off. But regardless of whether you're on or off nothing could explain my lobster bisque which arrived, literally, with a very small assortment of minced lobster and reportedly crawfish in the bottom of the bowl onto which one poured the bisque. My scallops were grilled correctly but arrived just barely warm. The salads are ridiculous... About $3 for each of the 3 little greens. This place is minimalist to be sure... Except for the prices. For me,the service was slow, obsequious and intrusive. In nice restaurants I prefer the service that is so good you don't even notice it. Not so here. I'm glad so many people had a great experience but, personally, I won't even give them a 2nd chance.