We had been regulars at Kelsey's for several years (up to three nights a week when we were busy and unable to cook) Unfortunately, the other reviewers are correct- things have gone downhill very quickly. I don't know if it was the change in adding Gino's pizza or what.
They also changed their prices/menu significantly after they added Gino's. That normal sandwich/burger and fries went from 9.99 to 12.99+. That was a significant jump with absolutely no increase in quality or taste.
Servers are so hit or miss now. Most are new faces, but they seem to be poorly trained and overwhelmed. On our last (and likely final) visit, I actually went up to the bar to wait for a soda refill because we couldn't find our server (or any server) anywhere. We had an issue with the bill (charged for a salad we never received) and they acted like they were doing us a favor for taking it off the bill when we never received the darned thing!
The quality of the daily menu options has also dropped. They used to offer interesting and tasty plates as nightly specials and now they are just nothing that even sounds good.
It's a shame as we like to support local restaurants, but the owners at Kelsey's had better wake up and start fixing a few things. I would probably try one more time, but my husband is done.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.