We chose AJ's based on recommendations found here and because we were staying on Tybee. We went on a Thursday night (Oct 7) and arrived around 6pm. There was a bit of a wait but were able to sit outside with drinks in hand, so all was good. Our table wound up being the closest one to the water, therefore having a front row seat for the sunset. Since it was also our grandmother's 86th birthday, this could not have worked out any better. The food was good, the service fantastic and prices reasonable. They were busy at the time yet our waitress handled all six of us (in our party) like a pro. If we're back in Tybee again, we'd certainly go back to AJ's. Only one word of caution: if you like hushpuppies, they serve them at room temperature but since they state that right there on the menu there is no room for complaining.