Gustavos has a great location right on the square (near the General Store) with a new expanded location. Hands down some of the best pizza I have ever had. But I can't give 5 stars for a couple reasons. 1-it is touch and go on whether they are ever open. On two occasions I planned to go there with a group and they were closed. One time was Wednesday for dinner and another time was a lunch. 2-the set up in the new location is a little uncomfortable. You enter and order and pay at a counter. You then go to a separate bar if you want a beer and pay there. You ten sit and they bring you your food but you clean your own table (which I hate). They also serve Pepsi and not Coke.
I saw another review suggested getting the pizza to go and that is a great suggestion. The pizza is excellent and is true New York style and delicious. Best to enjoy it at home with a Coke :)
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.