We've been to this restaurant under several iterations... not a lot of changes to the interior since the last one. It's nice, comfortable, and reminiscent of a pub.
Food was very good. Not a huge selection, and more fried food than one might expect, but lots of options, and everything we had was very good, well prepared, and amply portioned. Prices were quite reasonable... we routinely spend more at chain restaurants.
Service was prompt and professional. They had no record of our reservation, but this wasn't a problem... they still seated us immediately.
Was kind of a busy night Saturday night, though not sold out. Big private party on the patio (nice space for a private party), live music up front, and quite a few folks on the Central Avenue deck taking in the car show scene.
Bonus Tip: One of Winter Haven's better kept secrets, the FREE Avenue A parking garage, is one block away. Always a good alternative to on-street parking.