Umatilla, is a small town in Central Florida stuffed between Eustis and Altoona. Nicky D's is modest inside and out, however, the dining experience needs to be shared. Ordering from their vast Italian menu, I had Baked Eggplant, and with a generous portion of Calamari appetizer, I was ready for a to-go box before the main course arrived. The huge portions of baked Eggplant and side penne pasta was fantastic. The flavor kept me eating even after the brain said stop. We boxed at least 3/4 of the meal and thoroughly enjoyed it for lunch the next day..
A definite must if passing through Central Florida on Highway 19.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.