During our 1 week vacation at Siesta Key, FL we visited Der Dutchman twice for dinner. Next year we will definitely try breakfast. From the uber fresh salad stuffs to the home cooking veggies and entrees and finally the chocolate cake and ice cream finale, we were blown away. The chowder was great, the mustard eggs were a new tasty experience, the broasted chicken was juicy, the mashed potatoes perfect, the homemade noodles yummy, and roast beef was melt in your mouth good. In fact everything we tried we liked except the stuffing (texture was odd). Be sure you try the vanilla ice cream at the end with the chocolate cake. They have a peanut butter sauce on the tables, give it a try. You will probably find yourself buying the big bottle as you leave. It's great on toast for a quick breakfast on the go. The bakery sells fried pies 1.99 each. We tried 4 different flavors and weren't blown away but live to try some of the other treats next year. The restaurant was very clean and have private rooms for larger groups to dine together.
I almost forgot, they had a smoked sausage one evening when we were there that my husband and son raved over.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.