I relocated from NY to Sarasota in 2012, leaving behind many great eating spots that I had grown up loving. Once I heard about the Fella, I thought to myself, hmm, they're from NY, maybe there's hope. I was definitely not disappointed on my first visit, and I've been back almost at least once a week since. There is nothing on their menu that I wouldn't try but my favorite is #14, the meatball parm sub. The store is decorated nicely with touches from Italy & NY, and the staff is super friendly, it's a must to have a meal here whether you're a local or just visiting SRQ.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.