We showed up at GF at 6:30 on a Friday night with a party of 10, unannounced. They moved some tables around to accommodate us and got us seated in about 10 minutes.
Between all of us, we ordered salads, pasta dishes, lasagna and pizza. Everything was made on site - the pasta, the sausage, the wine; everything. The DIY salad dressing table was a cool concept and the oils and vinegars were creative and tasty. We also bought a pound of coffee which the owner roasted and ground for us to order. It was terrific. The value at Goodfellas is quite good and the personal touches we received really made it stand out. Next time we visit Sarasota, I'll try to make sure GF's is on the agenda!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.